Serene Siren has gotten married to Spencer Scott, so Serene's stepdaughter Lexi Lore and Spencer's stepdaughter Chloe Temple are now stepsisters. This will be Lexi's first day going to the same school as Chloe. Serene and Spencer give the teens their lunches in paper bags, and lovingly wish them a good day. The teens then leave for school.
Later that day, Lexi and Chloe arrive home, but their hair and school uniforms look disheveled. Serene and Spencer are shocked and worried, asking what happened. The teens seem hesitant to talk about it, so Serene and Spencer decide to prioritize looking after the teens first. Spencer gets a first aid kit, then she and Serene lovingly dote on the teens and patch them up. The teens eventually explain what happened: some other students were making nasty comments about Serene and Spencer because they're lesbians, so Lexi started fighting with them, and then Chloe jumped in to help Lexi.
Serene and Spencer are touched that the teens wanted to stand up for them, and they're especially touched that Chloe jumped in to help Lexi. It's lovely that their family has become so close! However, Serene and Spencer say that the next time other students say mean things, it's better to either talk things out with the students or just ignore them. The teens apologize for taking things too far, explaining how deeply they love Serene and Spencer, and that they also took the insults personally because they've realized that THEY are lesbians too. The teens also admit to being attracted to the stepmoms. Serene and Spencer are surprised and a bit hesitant at first, but then decide to help the teens explore these feelings. This family is clearly close and protective of each other, so why not get even closer?